Cedarburg's home for Mac & Cheese, Paninis, and homemade custard.
Out & Out Eatery and Catering Historic Cedarburg
W61N305 Washington Avenue, Cedarburg, WI
Pickup Only
Featured Items

Original Mac & Cheese
The One That Started It All...VEGETARIAN$4.99+
Kids Meal
$7.99
Americano
Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mozzarella & Garlic Mayo$8.99
Food Menu
Mac & Cheeses
It's what we're famous for. Whether it's an Original Mac & Cheese or one of our many rotating special concoctions, we've got the best Mac & Cheese around!

Original Mac & Cheese
The One That Started It All...VEGETARIAN$4.99+
Special: Ham & Gouda Mac
Our Original Mac & Cheese topped with fresh sliced Ham and gooey shredded Gouda. A Portion of the proceeds go to Epilepsy Foundation of Wisconsin$8.99+
3-Cheese Chicken
Chicken, Provolone, Feta, and topped with Garlic Breadcrumbs$8.99+
Garden Pesto Mac
Our Original Mac & Cheese topped with basil pesto, roasted broccoli and fresh red peppers. A fresh, flavorful twist on a classic favorite.$8.99+
Cajun Mac
Chicken, Andouille Sausage, Red Bell Peppers, & Cajun SeasoningSPICY$8.99+
Bacon Carbonara
A Classic Out & Out staple. Bacon, Peas and Crispy Onions layered on top of our Original Mac & Cheese$8.99+
Kids Meals
A kid-friendly combo with one main, one side, and one drink. Simple, familiar, and just the right size.

Kids Meal
$7.99
Original Mac & Cheese Pan
Our Famous Original Mac & Cheese for a group or family. Comes cold with heating instructions. Serves 6-8 as an entree or up to 20 as a side dish.

Family Size Pan (comes cold with heating instructions)
Our Original Mac & Cheese - Family or Group Size. Feeds 6-8 as an entree or up to 20 as a side.$36.99
Paninis

Americano
Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mozzarella & Garlic Mayo$8.99
Chipotle Chicken
Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Cheddar & Chipotle Mayo$8.99
Cuban
Pork, Ham, Dill Pickle Slices, Swiss, & Mustard Mayo$8.99
Caprese
Pesto Sauce, Balsamic Glaze, Mozzarella, Tomatoes and Salt & Pepper.$8.99
Grilled Cheese
Classic Cheddar Grilled Cheese$5.99
Wraps

Turkey Club Wrap
Turkey, Bacon, Smashed Avocado, Tomato, Cheddar and Greens on a White Wrap$8.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Provolone, Ranch & Greens on White Wrap$8.99
Cranberry Turkey
Turkey, Cranberry Sauce, Pecans, Herb Cream Cheese & Greens on White Wrap$8.99
Chicken Caesar
Chicken, Asiago, Greens, Garlic Breadcrumbs, Caesar Dressing on Whole Wheat Wrap$8.99
Falafel
Falafel, Feta, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Banana Peppers, Greens & Tzatziki Sauce on Wheat Wrap$8.99
Salad & Grain Bowls

Pecan Chop
Pecan, Craisins, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Carrots on Greens with Feta & Balsamic Vinaigrette$9.49
Mandarin
Mandarin Oranges, Cashews, Tomatoes, Carrots, Cucumbers& Greens with Sesame Honey Dressing$9.49
Thai Sesame
Quinoa, Kale Cabbage Blend, Red Cabbage, Carrots, Edamame, Cucumber, Cilantro, Green Onion, Peanuts, and Sesame Honey DressingVEGETARIAN$9.49
Southwest Quinoa
Quinoa, Kale Cabbage Blend, Red Cabbage, Mango, Roasted Corn, Black Beans, Cilantro, Sunflower Seeds, and Chipotle Lime Vinaigrette$9.49
Field Salad
Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Carrots and Greens with Ranch Dressing$6.99
Soup
Vegetable Barley
Homemade Soups by Chris - This week's creation is Vegetable Barley$3.99+
Sides

Kettle Chips
Miss Vickie's Kettle Chips (Various Flavors)$1.50+
Grape Uncrustable
One for the littliest Out & Out'ers$2.49
Baby Carrots
Baby Carrots with Side of Ranch$1.25
Banana
Fresh Banana$1.00
Custard Menu
Dirty Sodas
Classic sodas get an Out & Out twist! Fun flavor combinations mixed with fruity syrups, creamy cold foam and plenty of fizz. Pick your favorite and get a little dirty.
Special: Grape Dreamsicle
Sprite Soda mixed with Grape and topped with delicious Cold Foam A portion of all proceeds go to Epilepsy Foundation of Wisconsin$4.99
Campfire Dream
Mr. Pibb with toasted marshmallow and cherry syrups, topped with smooth vanilla sweet cold foam. Sweet, creamy and campfire-inspired.$4.99
Creamsicle Crush
Orange Fanta with coconut syrup, topped with smooth vanilla sweet cold foam for a creamy, tropical twist on a classic orange treat.$4.99
Blue Hawaiian
A tropical blend of blue raspberry, pineapple and lime syrups, topped with smooth vanilla sweet cold foam.$4.99
Razzle Dazzle
Sprite with blue raspberry and cherry syrups for a bright, fruity and refreshingly fizzy combination.$4.99
Sunset Splash
Orange Fanta with cherry and pineapple syrups for a bright, tropical burst of fruity flavor.$4.99
Cherry Limeade
Sprite with sweet cherry and zesty lime syrups for the perfect balance of sweet, tart and refreshing.$4.99
Custard

Create Your Own Custard
Our Unique Blend of Custard with your Choice of up to 3 Toppings$3.99+
Plain Custard
Out & Out's One of a Kind Custard Flavor$2.99+
Pup Cup
$1.99
Kids Cup
1/2 Scoop of Chocolate or Vanilla with complimentary sprinkles for our littlest fans$1.99
Custard Stand Classics
Special: Chai Shake
Chai and Vanilla Custard, topped with Whipped Cream and Cinnamon$4.99
Arnold Palmer
Frozen Lemonade and Iced Tea$3.99
Custard Smoothies
Custard & Fruit Balance Each Other Out Right?$4.99
Frozen Fresh-Squeezed Lemonade
What's More Summer Than This?$3.99
Hand Spun Shakes & Malts
Out & Out Custard & Your Flavor of Choice Create an All-Time Classic$4.99+
Lemon Ice Float
Vanilla Custard & Fresh Squeezed Lemonade!$4.99
Slushies
Perfect for a Quick Cooldown!$2.99
Soda Floats
The WI version of an All-Time Classic$4.99
Popular Combinations
Special: Apple Pie Sundae
Vanilla Custard, Apple Pie Filling, and topped with Cinnamon Streusel$3.99+
Oreo Brownie Bliss
Vanilla Custard top with Oreos, Brownie Dough & Hot Fudge$3.99+
S'more Sundae
Vanilla Custard, Graham Crackers, Marshmallow Cream & Hot Fudge$3.99+
Turtle Sundae
Vanilla Custard, Pecans, Caramel & Hot Fudge$3.99+
Hot Fudge Sundae
Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge & Whipped Cream w/Cherry on Top$3.99+
Beverage Menu
Beverages

Fountain Beverage
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Mello Yellow, Orange Fanta, Pibb Xtra, or Sprecher Root Beer$2.69
Bottled Water
$0.99
Milk
$1.99
Honest Apple Juice
$1.79
New
Dirty Soda
Special: Grape Dreamsicle
$4.99
Sprite Soda mixed with Grape and topped with delicious Cold Foam A portion of all proceeds go to Epilepsy Foundation of Wisconsin
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1